The Inner Battle

February 8, 2009

Image credit: heart thrb

Since writing my post on Peaceful Thoughts about the vow of non-violence in thought, words and action, I have been contemplating  this subject of non-violent thoughts more deeply. I reread the second chapter of the Bhagavad Gita in which Arjuna the Pandava prince, friend and devotee of Lord Krishna, is counseled as he  is about to engage in  battle. The battle is supposed to be symbolic of the inner battle that we all endure. Lord Krishna’s advice to Arjuna as he lay despondent and confused is appropriate to this discussion on what taking a vow of peace means.

The great Mahabharata war between the Pandavas and the Kauravas took place after the failure of Lord Krishna’s peace mission on behalf of the Pandavas, over their rightful share of the kingdom. All the famous warriors from both sides had assembled on the battlefield. Lord Krishna was the charioteer of Arjuna. The two armies were  magnificently arrayed, amid the din of hundreds of conches blaring, announcing the commencement of the battle. Arjuna was bewildered by the scene before him, for on both sides were his family members, distant relatives, friends and teachers. He became confused. Should he participate in this terrible carnage? Was it worth killing one’s relatives for the sake of a kingdom and some pleasures? Would it not be better for him to surrender everything in favor of his enemies and retire in peace? He sank into despondency letting the bow slip from his hands. He could not go through with it. He turned to Lord Krishna for guidance.

Lord Krishna rebuked Arjuna for his dejection which was due to attachment and told him to fight. The Lord took pity on Arjuna and began to enlighten him by different means. He explained the nature of the Self, that Arjuna should not grieve as the Self never dies, has no past, present or future; that freedom lies in the ability to be balanced in the experience of pleasure and pain alike.

The Lord went on to say that the performance of action without expectations as to gain and loss, victory or defeat is detachment. “These are in the hands of the Lord. He should perform all action with a balanced mind, calmly enduring the pairs of opposites like heat and cold, pleasure and pain, that inevitably manifest during action. Krishna advises Arjuna to fight, free from desire for acquisition of kingdom or preservation of it.”

The Bhagavad Gita ends with the eighteenth chapter where the Lord said to Arjuna in Verse 59: If resolved with egotism you think, “I will not fight,” this resolve is  in vain; your own nature will compel you. And in verse 60: Bound by your own Karma born of your own nature, what you wish not to do, through delusion, you shall do that against your will.

In contemplating these words and thinking about the vow of non-violent thoughts I have come to an understanding that we will have violent thoughts due to our karma. The danger of taking a vow is that we may feel towards ourselves, disappointment, anger, shame or regret which are violent thoughts. We continue to create a karmic cycle of violence to ourselves which reverberates to the outside world of our existence.

The symbolism of the Mahabharata war for me is the need to end our inner afflictions of anger, jealousy, greed, doubt etc. by doing battle with them. We allow the seeds of past karma to manifest as they will, with equanimity of mind but to disrupt the creation of the cycle of karma  with the aid of understanding and awareness.

In There Is No Suffering,  Master Sheng-Yen said,“Thoughts still create karma, but without corresponding speech and action, the karma created is light…Through practice we begin to reflect after the act. Gradually, with growing awareness, we reflect before we act. This is cultivation. We slowly move from action to non-action, where karma creation is concerned. Some might think it best to lock oneself in a room to avoid creating any more karma. In fact you will still receive retribution from previous lives, so you may as well live meaningfully, and cultivate goodness. Besides, you will create karma as long as your mind continues to be moved by things and events, so it does not matter whether you lock yourself up or not. Afflictions will still follow you like a shadow… When thoughts arise do not reject them or deny them. Just being aware of them is usually enough to dissipate them. If they persist, count or observe your breaths, or recite the Buddha’s name.”

Related Post: Musings on War and Peace


1 Lea 02.09.09 at 10:21 am

Thank you for your interpretation of this segment of the Bhagavad Gita. When I first read this book, I was disturbed and confused by the statement “war is necessary,” or words to that affect.

With your interpretation, I now realize I was thinking in terms of worldly war, which I feel is useless, instead of our inner personal wars that each of us wage at one time or another, whether we’re on the path to enlightenment or not.

I admit I found the Bhagavad Gita very deep and challenging. I might attribute that to being a Westerner, but even a Hindu that I quizzed on this “war is necessary” quote, didn’t understand why this would be so.

Thank you for helping me get a better perception. Have a great day

2 Mark 02.09.09 at 11:35 am

Interesting! In the end of the day, it is how we love and that we are love. I believe that we should do no harm in any way. When we have harmful thoughts, we should do no harm to our self and allow the thought to flow and to not beat our self up over the thought. Doing no harm also means and very importantly means do no harm to our self.

3 Miruh 02.10.09 at 8:56 pm

Hello Lea,

Thanks for dropping by.

The Bhagavad Gita is an enigma, but looking at it from the perspective of metaphor, it is a great philosophy to live by.

Still, the reference to duty is important, for the caste system had its usefulness in that society. Whether or not war is ethical or useful, it is interesting that it is part of the scriptures of Eastern and Western religions except maybe the Buddhist.

I read it for the wisdom it teaches and consider it a myth.

May you be embraced in soft peace and warm love!

4 Miruh 02.10.09 at 9:03 pm

Hello Mark,

I agree, “it is how we love and that we are love. I believe that we should do no harm in any way. ”

To live in a way in which we respect ourselves and all of creation, sentient and insentient is the highest aspiration. Only when we have this awareness, we can evolve to know the Truth.

Thanks for your gracious presence and words or wisdom.

Deep peace to you!

Comments on this entry are closed.